Thailand only feeds Muslim discontent
 
Philip Bowring International Herald Tribune
Thursday, October 28, 2004
HONG KONG At the beginning of this year, Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra of Thailand was being touted as the new informal leader of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations. Now he may be Asean's greatest embarrassment after Myanmar's military strongman, Than Shwe.
.
The deaths this week of 84 unarmed Muslim demonstrators in southern Thailand was tragic enough in itself. Six appear to have been shot dead and more than a dozen wounded, while 78 died later of asphyxiation while being transported in army trucks.
.
Just as shocking as the deaths themselves, which may have been due to unfortunate accident rather than design, was Thaksin's callous reaction. He commended the anti-riot forces for their work, claimed that "many of the protesters appeared to be in a drug-induced state" and suggested that those who died did so not because of the military but "because they were in a weak physical condition resulting from fasting." In short, the dead had only themselves to blame.
.
Thaksin's crude remarks and the behavior of the Thai forces cannot be written off as a matter for Thais alone. The unhappiness of Thailand's three southern, predominantly Muslim, Malay-speaking provinces has international implications - for the West in its self-proclaimed "war on terror"; for Asean, in which Muslims are the largest religious group; and for Malays in Malaysia, who inevitably sympathize with their brethren across the border. The West has enlisted Thailand in its war on terror, and Thaksin has been praised for his support, which has earned the offer of a free trade agreement with the United States. But his government's actions in the south have been creating just the kind of discontent on which Muslim fundamentalism thrives, and resorting to strong-arm methods that engender terrorism and violent reaction.
.
The news from Thailand will be a recruiting slogan for militants in Indonesia, Malaysia and the Philippines and will provide nourishment for the international jihadists who use such local Muslim discontent as cover for their own, grander plans.
.
During the past year of troubles in the south, Bangkok's policy toward the region has been confused at best. While there has been talk of conciliation, the reality has been the often heavy hand of the military. The highly centralized Thai state shows little sign of being willing or able to address the needs of a region that is so different.
.
Thailand's three southern provinces once formed the Sultanate of Pattani. In retrospect it is unfortunate that in the early 20th century the British did not carry out their plans to detach Pattani from Thai sovereignty, as they did with the Malay states of Kedah, Perlis, Kelantan and Terengganu, which are now part of Malaysia. Nor did the victors in 1945 punish Thailand, as they once intended, for its pro-Japan wartime posture by joining these provinces to Malaya.
.
To their credit, Asean members have so far avoided revanchist thoughts and committed themselves to respecting the borders, however illogical, that were set in colonial times. But it is hard to imagine Thai-Malaysian relations remaining on an even keel if Bangkok treats its Malay-Muslim region the way the Kremlin treats Chechnya.
.
Thaksin's government has cast shadows over Thailand's bright, young democracy in several ways: the apparent widespread use of extra-judicial killings during a war on drugs, various allegations of favoritism toward related businesses, and the use of pressure on the news media to curtail criticism of his government.
.
Those may be viewed as matters for the Thai people, who elected him nearly four years ago and will soon have the opportunity to vote him out of office. But Thaksin's words and his government's actions in the south are of international concern. Thailand, the premier state of mainland southeast Asia, is too important to let this go without public rebuke by both its neighbors and its many foreign friends.
.

next
previous


    E-mail This Article Print Article Text Larger Text Small Single Column Multi Column